Columbus, Christianity and Racism (20211011)

Columbus  Day, which the United States celebrates as a federal holiday on the second Monday of October, should force one to reflect on the problem of racism and white supremacy in the country. The history of this problem is long, and Christians contributed to it right from the day Christopher Columbus arrived in the Americas on October 12, 1492.

Perhaps it is time to completely drop Columbus Day. Columbus was a ruthless tyrant who played a key role in initiating the two greatest crimes in the history of the Western Hemisphere -- the Atlantic slave trade and the genocide of American indigenous people.Jesus brought life and truth but many of his later followers followed his teachings very selectively. Christians today – even those who reside in Rome — are not infallible.When they sin and fall into error, however, they must do more than simply apologize and feel bad. They have to repair the damage.

Christianity and racism in the New World

This  week some historic as well as contemporary reflections about Christianity and racism in the New World.On May 4, 1493, just a year after Christopher Columbus arrived in the New World, Pope Alexander VI (not a striking example of moral rectitude for sure) issued his papal bull Inter Caetera. Alexander was far more interested in wealth and power than spirituality. His document which became known for proclaiming "the Doctrine of Discovery" announced that any land not inhabited by Christians was open to be "discovered" by Christian rulers and that "the Catholic faith and Christian religion be exalted and be everywhere increased and spread… and that the barbarous nations be overthrown…."

The Doctrine of Discovery produced clear examples of how racist ideas of supremacy over Indigenous peoples were used not only to justify but to sanctify the seizure of occupied Indigenous lands, the physical removal of communities to undesirable reservations, and systematic genocidal violence. There is much about U.S. history that can make one proud of being American. Unfortunately, the nation's history also attests that too often American Christianity promoted and sustained racism through the brutal colonialism of missionaries and the enforced segregation of its churches.

Taking land, enslaving people

The majority of early American colonists did not recognize the deep culture and traditions of Native peoples, nor did they acknowledge their tribal land rights. They sought to convert the Native people in the New World and at the same time strip them of their land.Newcomers from England during the 17th Century, for example, saw themselves as settling in a "virgin land" where real "civilization" had not yet been established.

From the colonial period onwards, relations between European and Native peoples were predominantly expressed and negotiated in terms of land. The issue of land became, in many ways, the deepest "religious" issue over which world views collided. Many of the colonists saw the new land as a "wilderness" to be settled in, not as already inhabited.They also saw the New World as the New Promised Land and considered the Indigenous peoples like the Canaanites of old, to be conquered and removed. John Winthrop (1588–1649), an English Puritan lawyer and governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony, was convinced that God favored his community above all others.In 1641 Winthrop helped write the Massachusetts Body of Liberties, the first legal sanctioning of slavery in North America.

The rise of white supremacy

About 140 years later, in a 1783 sermon celebrating the American Revolution, Yale University president Ezra Stiles praised the rise of the "whites" whose numerical growth, he said, proved divine favoritism. Interestingly, there were almost 700,000 African slaves in the United States by 1790, which equated to approximately 18% of the total population. White supremacy.

Over the course of nearly three centuries, American Indigenous peoples were "removed" from the lands they had occupied, "displaced" to other lands, and had their lands "ceded" to the newcomers. Then, native tribes were forcibly "settled" on "reservations." Early Christian slaveholders used the Bible to justify the enslavement of darker-skinned people. Vigilante groups terrorized Black Americans as the vigilantes rode around in white hoods with the Bible in hand. Prominent evangelical pastors spewed racist hatred against America's first Black president.And most recently of course we have witnessed racial hate crimes, murders, and police brutality.

Racism is a virus

So what do we do once we realize that religious actors have been complicit in forming and upholding American racism? What might we do to correct racism? Certainly racial justice will not come just from individual acts of charity. It will require the transformation of our social structures. Racism is systemic.A failure to grasp the systemic nature of racism could explain why the United States has not made as much progress as it should—and could—on racial equity. Racism is a virus. Like the coronavirus, if ignored it will not disappear. 

Many people have a too narrow view of racism that has really blocked racial progress.They fail to understand systemic racism and are, therefore, more likely to attribute poverty, for example, to individual failings rather than to structural disadvantages like racial disparities in wealth and wages and substandard education for Blacks. Segregated housing, too, has left many Black people living in neighborhoods without access to good jobs, reliable public transportation, or quality health care.

A challenge to Catholic leadership

As  President Joe Biden said following the conviction of former police officer Derek Chauvin, who was found guilty of second-degree murder and manslaughter, the killing of George Floyd "ripped the blinders off for the whole world to see the systemic racism" that has become a "stain on our nation's soul".Combating racism is a particular challenge to U.S. Catholic leadership. "The American Catholic bishops are frequently criticized by the left and the right for what they say in the political arena…But it's what the bishops haven't said, particularly on racial justice, that has kept them from being a more prophetic voice in American life," noted Thomas Reese SJ last April in an article published by Religion News Service. "Few if any bishops, for example, have participated in the Black Lives Matter movement or said anything about voter suppression laws. 

African Methodist Episcopal clergy, on the other hand, have rallied and threatened boycotts over voter suppression bills in state legislatures across the country. The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops has said nothing," Reese pointed out."The reluctance of Catholic bishops to take on racial issues has deep roots in Catholic history. Catholic bishops did not lead in the abolition movement. Catholic immigrants, many of them poor, did not want to die to free Black slaves," the Jesuit writer concluded.

Some encouraging signs from the Jesuits

I am neither anti-Christian nor anti-American, but -- to be very honest -- we all have a lot of transformative work to do. I share Reese's concerns about U.S. Catholic leadership; but I also applaud some positive Catholic signs which give encouragement and guidance. The honesty and efforts towards reparation that Georgetown University in Washington, DC and the Jesuit Community there have undertaken are prophetic examples.In 1838, the Jesuits sold 272 Black men, women, and children and used the proceeds to support their university, which had been founded in 1789 by Bishop John Carroll.

 I find it noteworthy and encouraging that in September 2015, Georgetown President John J. DeGioia established a Working Group on Slavery, Memory, and Reconciliation. This led to dialogue with and an apology to descendants of the slaves who were sold. Georgetown today is making key efforts to address the legacy of slavery and overcome racism at the university, in Washington, and beyond. In March of this year, the Society of Jesus in the United States announced the establishment of the Descendants Truth & Reconciliation Foundation, a collaborative effort among Jesuits, Georgetown, and some descendants to raise $100 million to help address the legacy of enslavement in the United States and its impact on families and communities today.

Watch your language, it's not funny

We  really need to conscientiously and collectively combat racism. We need to be alert to language, jokes, slogans, and labeling.

 In the January 6th attack on the U.S. Capitol, a demonstrator wore a shirt with the words "Camp Auschwitz" printed on it. That action was a sinister danger sign. Auschwitz-Birkenau survivor, Fritzie Fritzshall, was greatly upset. "That made my stomach turn," she said. "Why do they have to still wear T-shirts about hatred and stuff like that? That's what the Nazis did. That's exactly what they did." 

We need to critique and work to improve educational, employment, and police policies and actions. Friction, for example, between African Americans and the police is a reality that should be immediately addressed. We need to be alert to signs of racism in our churches, neighborhoods, and social groups. We need to be alert as well to increased anti-Semitism. Violent anti-Semitism and hatred did not end with the Holocaust. According to the Anti-Defamation League, anti-Semitic incidents in the United States reached their highest on record in 2019. Assault, harassment, and vandalism against Jews remain at near-historic levels in the United States today.

For further reading, I recommend: The Sin of White Supremacy: Christianity, Racism and Religious Diversity in America (Orbis, 2017) by Jeannine Hill Fletcher, Professor of Theology at Fordham University.

John Alonso Dick, born in 1943 in Michigan (USA),is an historical theologian and former academic dean at the American College, KU Leuven (Belgium) and professor the KU Leuven and the University of Ghent. His latest book is Jean Jadot: Paul's Man in Washington (Another Voice Publications, 2021).

This article was first published on La Croix International at https://international.la-croix.com/news/world/columbus-christianity-and-racism/15030?utm_source=NewsLetter&utm_medium=Email&utm_campaign=20211013_mailjet

______