This Constitution, intended for the governance of the whole Catholic Church,
is offered to be of service to the Catholic Church throughout the world, for
adoption or adaptation according to local needs. It has relevance to local
communities, parishes, dioceses, national and other groups right through to
General Councils, and for all officers of the church.
The text of the Constitution, including its Preamble section, in its
consultative form has been widely available through both the Internet and
local groups and organizations. It was therefore not intended to have been
written from an exclusively Western world perspective.
This document is a governance document. Some readers may therefore be
disappointed that it is not written or expressed in theological language or
in terms of ecclesiology, e.g., it does not list the aims which the church
exists to serve. But governance is its focus, in order to concentrate the
competence in this much neglected aspect. However, it has been drawn up
from the pastoral perspective, recognizing that the principal level or forum
of Christian life takes place at community or parish level, and therefore,
through the notion of subsidiarity, it is at that local level where most of
the decision-making should take place. It is only when matters have a wider
consequence, or are beyond the competence of the community that decisions
take place at other levels. This Constitution is radically different from
the pyramid model, which in the church has evolved over the centuries
resulting with the Pope & Vatican at the pinnacle, the laity at the bottom,
and with the priests, bishops and religious orders somewhere in between.
In presenting this Constitution it is emphasized that the Preamble must
also is given the same status as the text for the governance of the church.
The Preamble contains essential statements relating to humanity within the
context of creation, our commitment through Baptism to proclaiming the
Gospel, and places our rights and responsibilities in that context.
The intention of this Constitution is to empower the Christian community
to proclaim the Gospel of the Kingdom. The emphasis is twofold:
- (1) that through Baptism everyone has a common membership, therefore
status cannot be accorded because of a specific role, vocation or
commissioning. There are no classes of membership.
- (2) maximum decision-making authority is placed with the local
christian community, as their responsibility, to develop their pastoral
role without external interference or restrictions. The members of the
community really are in control. Therefore decisions are only referred to
"broader" councils, e.g., diocese, or national when the matter is beyond
the competence of the community. This is therefore a reversal of what has
become familiar, i.e., where parishes are considered to be merely units of
a diocese, and all dioceses very much under the control of "rome." The
bishop no longer therefore has a plurality of roles: president, chief
executive, head of judiciary, as well as principal pastor of the diocese
instead, this Constitution frees the bishop to focus on diocesan-wide
pastoral responsibilities.
These two aspects restore a sense of balance to the role of the
individual member and his/her community within the context of the church.
The membership, parishes and communities really are key to the life of the
church. Thus the General Councils and the church officials become very much
servants (rather than masters) and there is, more importantly, the potential
mechanism for council decisions becoming implemented instead of foundering
on bureaucracy and apathy or abandoned through intimidation.
Finally, this document is no longer a draft.* This version was
produced jointly by the Association for the Rights of Catholics in the
Church (ARCC) with their European colleagues. At the January 1999 European
Network conference, it was presented as a Working Document to the member
groups. It is hoped that readers will find it encouraging and its eventual
adoption a possibility. Comments and responses are welcome, as a revised
version is planned in 2001.
John Gibson, European Network
*Note: Leonard Swidler, in his Introduction, calls this document a
draft. This is simply a matter of definition. Swidler uses the term "draft"
to indicate a document that continues to be open to study and revision, in
other words, a "working document."
|